Home
Explore
Guides

Country Tax Guides

All Guides Europe Americas Asia-Pacific Africa

VAT for Beginners

Indirect Tax 101
Tools
VAT Calculator GST Calculator Sales Tax Calculator VAT Number Check
Events Authors EN

Overviews

Court Decisions Expert Insights 🔊CJEU Podcast

Tax Updates

All News Europe Americas Asia-Pacific Africa

Topics

e-Invoicing Digital VAT Registration Tax Compliance and Reporting Tax Rates Nexus Tax Schemes Crypto Cross-Border Supply Customs ViDA Tax Returns

Indirect Taxes

VAT GST Sales and Service Tax Consumption tax PST Sales and Use Tax Digital Service Tax Excise Duty Japanese Consumption Tax

Other Taxes

Direct Taxes
Home
Learn About Tax
Tax News Tax Insights & Analyses Tax Guides Court of Justice of the European Union VAT for Beginners
Tools
VAT Calculator GST Calculator Sales Tax Calculator VAT Number Checker
Events Authors EN
Spain
Spain
Europe

Spain: Supreme Court on Tax Penalty Settlements and Appeals Limits

November 5, 2024
Spain: Supreme Court on Tax Penalty Settlements and Appeals Limits

The Central Economic-Administrative Court published its decision regarding the appeal of the Spanish resident referred to as Mr. Axy against the decision of the Central Economic-Administrative Court and Regional Economic-Administrative Court of Madrid to reject his claim against the agreement to impose a sanction of up to EUR 663,414.41.

What is vital in this decision is the background story that led to the dispute and the Supreme Court's quoting position concerning questioning the settlement that has become final.

Background Story of The Case and Supreme Court Position

After concluding the tax audit and inspection, the Tax Administration imposed penalties and fines on Mr. Axy for not respecting the VAT obligations. After receiving the notification from the Tax Administration, Mr. Axy signed a settlement agreement.

The settlement agreement concluded that in 2016, Mr. Axy issued an invoice that had nothing to do with economic activity since he did not perform any activity. Therefore, he confirmed that the invoices were false. Moreover, by signing the settlement agreement and admitting that there was no economic activity in 2016, Mr. Axy, it became apparent that there could be no VAT deduction related to the invoices issued by the supplier XZ Asociados SLP.

The Regional Inspection Unit of the Special Delegation of Madrid further determined that Mr. Axy's actions were intended to commit tax infringement and issued an agreement to impose a sanction of EUR 663,414.41.

This agreement was also signed and notified in 2021. However, Mr. Axy later appealed against the imposition of the sanctions, but the Regional Economic-Administrative Court of Madrid denied the appeal. Mr. Axy appealed against this decision as well before the Central Economic-Administrative Court.

The Central Economic-Administrative Court denied the appeal, stating that Mr. Axy admitted the wrongdoing. Furthermore, the signed agreement is unassailable, as no appeal for reconsideration or economic administrative claim has been filed against it.

To further cement its decision, the Central Economic-Administrative Court quoted the Supreme Court's position: once a settlement becomes final, its legality cannot be questioned simply because of a sanctioning agreement's challenge. Moreover, this rule applies when the violations in question do not require a settlement for the legal process to be valid. In simpler terms, questioning the legality of such a settlement is not allowed if the law does not demand a settlement in the first place.

Conclusion

The case presented describes the importance of court practice on tax and VAT-related disputes and the influence that decisions from the Constitutional and Supreme Courts have on the decisions made by lower courts.

In addition, this case provides valuable insight into the consequences that may arise from violating the tax and VAT-related rules and regulations. 

Source: Central Economic-Administrative Court Publication


Spain
Europe
Tax Compliance
VAT

VAT tax researcher, specializing in delivering clear, up-to-date insights on indirect tax regulations and compliance for our website. Rasmus Laan

Featured Insights

Supreme Administrative Court of Lithuania Practice on Appealing Tax Administrator Decisions

Supreme Administrative Court of Lithuania Practice on Appealing Tax Administrator Decisions

🕝 May 19, 2025

The Rise of E-Invoicing in Asia: Regulatory Changes and Business Impact

🕝 May 7, 2025

How to Apply Reverse Charge VAT for SaaS Companies

🕝 May 6, 2025

VAT on Digital Services in Argentina: What Foreign Providers Must Know

🕝 May 2, 2025

More News from Spain

Get real-time updates and developments from around the world, keeping you informed and prepared.

Can Regional Taxes Violate EU VAT Rules? ECJ Case C‑712/19 Ruling in Novo Banco Explained
Europe

Can Regional Taxes Violate EU VAT Rules? ECJ Case C‑712/19 Ruling in Novo Banco Explained

May 7, 2025
14 minutes
Spain Uncovers EUR 184M VAT Fraud: Tax Agency & Europol Investigation
Spain

Spain Uncovers EUR 184M VAT Fraud: Tax Agency & Europol Investigation

February 27, 2025
3 minutes
Spain's Franchised VAT Scheme: Key Changes for Freelancers Starting 2025
Spain

Spain's Franchised VAT Scheme: Key Changes for Freelancers Starting 2025

November 27, 2024
3 minutes
Spain's Proposed 21% VAT on Short-Term Rentals: What It Means for Landlords
Europe

Spain's Proposed 21% VAT on Short-Term Rentals: What It Means for Landlords

November 21, 2024
3 minutes
Spain: Supreme Court on Tax Penalty Settlements and Appeals Limits
Spain

Spain: Supreme Court on Tax Penalty Settlements and Appeals Limits

November 5, 2024
4 minutes
Spain Postpones Mandatory B2B E-Invoicing to 2027: New Timeline and Phases
Spain

Spain Postpones Mandatory B2B E-Invoicing to 2027: New Timeline and Phases

October 11, 2024
3 minutes
Spain: The European Commission Approved E-Invoicing
Spain

Spain: The European Commission Approved E-Invoicing

September 6, 2024
3 minutes
Country Guide - VAT in Spain
Spain

Country Guide - VAT in Spain

August 16, 2024
13 minutes
Spain - Tax Treatment of Live Services
Spain

Spain - Tax Treatment of Live Services

July 25, 2024
2 minutes
Spain: Tax Agency Clarifies VAT Treatment of the NFTs Granting Buyer Usage Rights
Spain

Spain: Tax Agency Clarifies VAT Treatment of the NFTs Granting Buyer Usage Rights

July 16, 2024
3 minutes
European Court of Justice Decision - VAT Deduction Rights for Low-Revenue Companies
Spain

European Court of Justice Decision - VAT Deduction Rights for Low-Revenue Companies

April 22, 2024
3 minutes

Stay Ahead of VAT Changes

Don’t miss out on crucial VAT developments that could impact your business or practice. 

Thanks for subscribing!
You can unsubscribe at any time.
VAT News Insights & Analyses Tax Guides Events About us Sponsors Authors Become a Contributor
Privacy policy
EU Tax Reform VAT News in Europe VAT for Digital Platforms Sales Tax GST ECJ Cases E-Invoicing
hello@vatabout.com