Transfers of a going concern occupy an awkward place in the VAT system. Article 19 of the VAT Directive allows Member States to treat them as falling outside the scope of a supply, with the recipient stepping into the transferor’s shoes. Most Member States have taken up that option, and the relief is now a routine assumption in succession planning across the Union.

On 9 September 2026, in Case T-366/25, the General Court addressed a question that the relief’s routine use had quietly left open: what happens when the business is split between several recipients at the moment of transfer, and reassembled only afterwards. The answer is that the relief does not apply, and that the intention to reassemble makes no difference.

The ruling also carries an institutional marker. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU or the Court) transmitted the reference to the General Court under Article 50b of the Statute, which since October 2024 has devolved preliminary references on the common system of VAT to the General Court. This is one of the first substantive VAT judgments delivered under that new allocation, by the Fifth Chamber sitting in extended composition.

The Facts Behind the Case

A Polish sole trader intended to gift his entire business to his two daughters, each receiving a 50 per cent share. He would retain none of the assets and would cease all economic activity immediately afterwards.

The daughters already ran a separate business together as a general partnership. They intended to absorb the gifted business into that partnership and carry on its activity in substantially unchanged form.

The tax authority refused the relief in an advance ruling issued in June 2020. In its view, where property is held in defined shares, each co-owner holds an exclusive title to that share and may dispose of it without the other’s consent. What was transferred, therefore, was not the business, but a share in each of the individual items composing it, which could not support an independent economic activity. It added that the activity would in fact be carried on by a third party, the partnership.

The court of first instance upheld that reasoning. On appeal, the Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny observed that Article 19 was also open to a functional reading, attentive to the purpose of the arrangement taken as a whole, and made the reference.

One Transaction, or Four?

The General Court structured its answer in two stages. It first asked whether the sequence of transactions could be treated as a single transaction, and only then whether the conditions of Article 19 were met.

The starting point is that each transaction must normally be regarded as distinct and independent. The exception is narrow: formally separate transactions are treated as one only where they are so closely linked that they objectively form a single indivisible economic supply, which it would be artificial to divide.

In the previous file, the Court found the elements pointing the other way. Each daughter received a share equal to half the business. The co-owners were separate legal persons, each holding exclusive title to her own share and free to dispose of it without the other’s consent. Each was therefore individually free to make, or not make, the subsequent contribution to the partnership. That contribution did not condition the first transaction, was independent of it, and would take place later.

That finding decides the case. Once the sequence is broken into four distinct transactions, two gifts and two contributions, the Article 19 analysis has to be carried out on each segment separately.

The Two Conditions, Tested Recipient by Recipient

The relief in Article 19 serves a practical purpose: it facilitates business transfers by sparing the recipient a substantial cash outlay that would in any event be recovered later through input tax deduction.

The conditions are settled, running from Zita Modes through Schriever, X and Mailat. The assets transferred must constitute an undertaking or part of an undertaking capable of carrying on an independent economic activity, and the transferee must intend to operate the business rather than immediately liquidate it.

The decisive step is the Court’s holding, following the Advocate General, that the first condition must be met in respect of each daughter, precisely because the transactions are separate and independent of one another. A share equal to half the business is not an autonomous set of assets and does not allow each recipient to carry on an independent economic activity on her own.

The judgment then states the rule in general terms. A transfer to two persons of a share corresponding to half an undertaking, such that neither can individually carry on an independent economic activity, fails the first condition, and does so regardless of their intention to contribute those shares to a company carrying on an economic activity in which they are partners. The second condition is not even examined.

The Point the Court Left Open

The European Commission had raised a preliminary objection worth noting. A gratuitous transfer is not, in principle, subject to VAT at all, so the question risked being hypothetical. The Court dismissed the objection by reference to the presumption of relevance that attaches to preliminary references.

The objection nonetheless identifies the real practical issue. Once the characterisation as a business transfer falls away, the treatment is reconstructed asset by asset, and the relevant rules deem an application of goods to non-business purposes a supply for consideration, limited to goods on which input tax was deducted. The taxable amount is the purchase price, or in its absence the cost price, determined at the time of the transaction.

The Court did not decide that question, nor did it decide what happens to the subsequent contributions. That second limb is the subject of separate proceedings still pending before the same Polish court.

The Italian Perspective

Italy exercised the Article 19 option under Article 2(3)(b) of the VAT decree, which excludes from the concept of a supply of goods transfers and contributions of businesses or branches of a business. Italian administrative practice applies the same substantive test developed by the Court of Justice, requiring an organised complex capable of independent operation rather than a bare collection of assets.

The difficulty lies elsewhere. Italian practice on generational succession has long been built on the opposite assumption. Administrative guidance going back to 1997 accepts that there is no limit on the number of beneficiaries of a gift of a business, who, by carrying on the donor’s activity, thereby form a de facto partnership between themselves. Later guidance treats the contribution of the business so received into a company as equivalent to continuing the business activity for the inheritance and gift tax relief.

In other words, continuity is secured precisely through the further entity, either the de facto partnership or the receiving company, that the General Court identifies as a reason for refusing Article 19 treatment. The two positions serve different tax purposes and rest on different premises, but a deed drafted under Italian law is now exposed on the VAT side.

The mismatch runs deeper. Italian income tax law renders a gratuitous business transfer neutral if the business is taken over at the transferor’s tax values, irrespective of the number of recipients. Gift tax relief, recast with effect from January 2025, requires recipients to carry on the business for at least five years and to state this in the deed. Neither regime asks whether what each recipient receives can function on its own. The same deed can therefore be neutral for income tax, exempt for gift tax, and taxable for VAT on the assets that once carried a deduction.

What This Means in Practice

The operative rule is that what is transferred must be capable of functioning on its own at the moment of transfer and in each recipient’s hands. Four structures satisfy this rule to varying degrees.

A gift to a single recipient is the safest route: one transfer, one complex, and any later contribution to a company is itself outside the scope. Dividing the business into genuinely autonomous branches also works, provided each branch has its own assets, contracts, employees, licences and liabilities, and the autonomy exists before the deed rather than being reconstructed afterwards.

Contributing the business to a company first and then gifting the shares reproduces the economic outcome of the Polish arrangement in a way that holds, because no undivided share of the business is ever transferred. Gifting the business directly to the entity that will operate it resolves the VAT question, but takes the recipient outside the scope of reliefs reserved for descendants and spouses.

Two further points merit attention. Transactions already completed but still within the assessment period should be reviewed, since the judgment interprets Article 19 rather than changing it. Where the composition of the business is uncertain, an advance ruling consolidates the characterisation while the choices remain reversible. The Polish case began, after all, with exactly such a request.

Conclusion

Case T-366/25 introduces no new principle. It applies the existing ones with a rigour that has immediate consequences for how business transfers are documented.

Article 19 is a simplification measure, not a general neutrality clause for succession planning. It operates where what is transferred is already, at the moment of transfer and for each recipient, an undertaking capable of functioning. The verification is objective, carried out transaction by transaction and recipient by recipient, and it is not corrected by the parties’ intention to reassemble the whole further downstream.

For advisers, the sequence has to be designed the other way round from current practice. The unit is built first and transferred second; fragments are not transferred in the expectation that the unit will reconstitute itself.